He Who Moans: Doctor Who Review: Robot of Sherwood (and the Gatiss showrunner question)

Given Gatiss’ name keeps being mentioned in connection with the “who’s gonna succeed Moffat?” question, I found this mutated into a much longer video than I expected. Cause while I really like Mark Gatiss – and I liked this episode incidentally – I really, reeeeally don’t think he’s the right guy for this particular job.

https://stubagful.wordpress.com

“The Doctor Who equivalent of Nyan cat – not a lot to it but it at least works”

Stuart Hardy

ALL FOOTAGE IS USED FOR THE PURPOSES OF CRITICISM AND REVIEW, ALL CREDIT IS GIVEN, DOCTOR WHO IS A TRADEMARK OF THE BBC AND I AM NOT PROFITING FROM THIS VIDEO IN ANY WAY

And now here is my artist’s conception of what this episode basically entails in a picture:

robotofsherwoodinanutshell

Advertisements

He Who Moans Doctor Who Editorial: Moffat’s Story Arcs and why they failed

Trolling Moffat Month: Episode 7: The Unsolvable Rubik’s Cube

Storylines: KNOW YOUR LIMITS

ALL FOOTAGE IS USED FOR THE PURPOSES OF CRITICISM AND REVIEW, ALL CREDIT IS GIVEN, DOCTOR WHO IS A TRADEMARK OF THE BBC AND I AM NOT PROFITING FROM THIS VIDEO IN ANY WAY

 

He Who Moans: Doctor Who Editorial: Is Doctor Who riding it’s reputation on Nostalgia?

Trolling Moffat Month: Episode 5: The Undermining of the Rani

INTERVIEWER: “Are you going to bring the Rani back?”

MOFFAT:”No because she wasn’t memorable enough”

ME: “…..then how did someone remember her in order to ask that question then?”

MOFFAT: Um…..look! Kittens!!

….yeah I’m making a lot of assumptions in this video but based on what he offers to the plate, its hard not to think this is his reasoning behind his decisions.

FOOTAGE USED FOR THE PURPOSES OF CRITICAL ANALYSIS AND REVIEW, OWNED BY THE BBC. ALL CREDIT IS GIVEN AND I AM NOT PROFITING FROM THIS VIDEO IN ANY WAY.

He Who Moans: Doctor Who Editorial: Steven Moffat Should Kill More Characters

Trolling Moffat Month: Episode 2: The Bizarre Misconception

So George R.R. Martin, Joss Whedon and Steven Moffat walk into a bar, and everyone you ever loved dies………….one of these things is not like the other two, who has Moffat actually killed again?

https://stubagful.wordpress.com/

ALL FOOTAGE AND IMAGES USED ARE OWNED BY THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS, FOOTAGE OF DOCTOR WHO IS USED FOR CRITICAL ANALYSIS AND REVIEW. DOCTOR WHO IS A TRADEMARK OF THE BBC.

He Who Moans: Doctor Who Editorials: Trolling Moffat Month

Before anyone starts accusing me of jumping on the anti-moffat bandwagon, I’m not. I don’t hate Moffat, I’m just monumentally disappointed with how his era’s turned out on the whole now the hype he had at the beginning of it has burned away, so I thought I’d try and explain why my opinion’s changed since 2010.

That and there’s enough videos on my channel of me bashing RTD and being way too nice to Moffat, call the next month of videos balance more than anything.

DOCTOR WHO IS A TRADEMARK OF THE BBC I AM UNAFFILIATED – THESE VIDEOS MADE FOR CRITICAL ANALYSIS AND REVIEW – NOT MADE FOR PROFIT. IMAGES OWNED BY OWNERS

And since my next few videos are likely to be controversial, I thought a seven minute long diatribe about what an opinion is and a polite request not to be threatened with eye socket rape was in order….for some reason I decided standing in a field and it should be in black and white were necessary in making it